Penny Value

Introduction & Value Overview The numismatic world was stunned in 2021 when an 1869 Indian Head Penny with the elusive doubled die obverse sold at Heritage Auctions for an impressive $38,400. This remarkable sale highlights why the 1869 Indian Head Penny remains one of the most coveted issues in the entire Indian Head cent series,…

Introduction & Value Overview The 1870 Indian Head Penny represents a pivotal issue in American numismatics, with premium examples commanding impressive prices at auction. In January 2023, a pristine PCGS MS-66 Red example sold for $21,600 at Heritage Auctions, demonstrating the significant value potential of this 155-year-old copper coin. While common circulated examples trade for…

Introduction & Value Overview The 1865 Indian Head Penny represents a pivotal year in American history and numismatics. Struck as the Civil War concluded, these pennies command impressive premiums in today’s market, with exceptional specimens recently fetching over $10,000 at auction. While common circulated examples typically range from $25-$75, uncirculated specimens can command $300-$3,500 depending…

Introduction & Value Overview In the realm of numismatics, few coins capture the essence of Civil War America like the 1864 Indian Head Penny. A remarkable transition year specimen, this coin commands impressive values in today’s market, with pristine examples regularly fetching $5,000 to $10,000. Recently, a PCGS MS-66+ RD example shattered expectations when it…

Introduction & Value Overview An exceptional 1866 Indian Head Penny recently commanded $23,500 at a Heritage Auctions sale, highlighting the extraordinary premium placed on pristine examples of this post-Civil War issue. While most circulated specimens trade in the $30-150 range, uncirculated gems can easily exceed $2,000, with the finest examples reaching well into five figures….

Introduction & Value Overview An 1867 Indian Head Penny in pristine MS66 Red condition commanded an impressive $28,200 at a Heritage Auction in 2019, highlighting the exceptional premium placed on top-grade examples of this post-Civil War issue. While common circulated specimens might sell for $25-$50, well-preserved uncirculated examples with original red luster can reach into…

In 1859, the United States Mint unveiled the 1859 Indian Head Penny, a coin that marked a pivotal shift in American numismatics. As the first year of the Indian Head cent series, it replaced the short-lived Flying Eagle cent and introduced a design that resonated with collectors for its artistic elegance and historical significance. A…

The 1860 Indian Head Penny represents a pivotal moment in American numismatic history, standing as the final issue before the tumultuous Civil War would forever change the nation’s coinage. As Abraham Lincoln prepared to take office, these copper cents circulated through an increasingly divided nation, making them silent witnesses to one of America’s most defining…

1. Introduction & Value Overview In 2023, a pristine 1862 Indian Head Penny graded PCGS MS66 sold at Heritage Auctions for $3,840, showcasing the coin’s potential for serious collectors. The 1862 Indian Head Penny, a copper-nickel cent from the Civil War era, commands attention due to its historical significance and diverse error and variety profiles….

Introduction & Value Overview An 1861 Indian Head Penny in exceptional MS-66 condition commanded an impressive $28,200 at a Heritage Auction in 2021, highlighting the extraordinary premium that top-grade examples of this Civil War-era coin can achieve. While most circulated specimens trade in the $20-$100 range, pristine uncirculated examples and those with rare errors can…